Mandatory Helmet Laws

You asked, so here it is; our position on helmet laws:

First, on the decision to wear a helmet: as an individual, it is a sensible decision to wear one when cycling. Especially if you engage in any of the behaviours that might make a crash more likely – including riding fast (for instance to be more visible and feel less vulnerable when you have to ride on the road in traffic); or riding on poor surfaces (like across the wheel-grabbing lip of any driveway in Brisbane. Or across the most important bicycle bridge in our city.) If you race, down-hill mountain bike, or love fanging down windy mountain roads, definitely wear a helmet! In the event of a crash where you hit your head, a helmet will probably help limit a skull injury, and may also offer some protection against a brain injury. Just as it would if you struck your head doing any of the those activities significantly more risky than cycling; such as using a ladder, or driving a car, or being a passenger in a car.


Helmets themselves are much less awful than they used to be when you and everyone you know stopped riding their bikes in the ’90s because you suddenly had to wear one. There are versions for as little as $20 to $50, and if you’re lucky you might be able to find one of those that you can adjust to fit properly and be somewhat comfortable. Unfortunately it is harder to find a way of combining a helmet with decent sun protection, so you will need to weigh this all against the very real and known risks of sun exposure.

On mandatory helmet laws: we know that on a population-wide basis, making it illegal to ride a bicycle without a helmet has reduced the numbers of people who regularly ride a bike. This has disproportionately affected people on low incomes, students, families with kids of different ages, and people who make the most short trips – typically women. Since most people who ride bikes now are doing it for sport, fitness, or recreation, and are most often middle-aged males dressed in custom sporting clothing, this has somehow led to a community perception that cycling is an activity for the indulgence of middle aged men in lycra, rather than a normal, practical and healthy method of transport for anyone. (And by the way, there is nothing whatsoever wrong with lycra; wear whatever is comfortable and practical when you ride your bike!)

We would rather the police were able to direct their energy where they can make the most difference to safety on our roads and to security (including perceptions of it) on off-road pathways, rather than spending resources fining healthy transport. We would rather politicians at all levels would stop being distracted by helmets (or bare heads) and get on with directing energy and resources to building better infrastructure and supporting legislation that would make it safer and more enjoyable for anyone to ride a bike.

If you basically support this position, you might be interested in joining Freestyle Cyclists on their ride on Saturday 17 March – appropriately titled “Stop Fining Healthy Transport”. You can choose to wear a helmet, or not. But if you don’t (and you haven’t complied with the laws enabling an exemption), the probability you will get a fine is much higher than the chance you will hit your head. Now we’ve got that all out of the way, here are the details of the ride/parade in Brisbane:

Saturday, March 17th 2018: Meeting at the Cultural Forecourt (South Bank) near the Wheel of Brisbane at 12:50pm to kick off proceedings from 1pm. The ride will go over the Goodwill Bridge to the Botanic Gardens and back. The pace will be inclusive of all and in keeping with pedestrian traffic. 

That’s it. That’s all we at Space4cyclingBNE have to say on the matter. This is one instance where we’re really not particularly interested in your opinion or your anecdote. We’ve all heard it all before. If you are especially passionate about the topic of mandatory helmet laws (either for or against), we encourage you to go and make your views known to your elected representative yourself, or join a group that is already lobbying on the issue, or form your own group if you don’t like the way someone else is doing it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s